Montgomery County, Virginia
Home  |  Calendar  |  Government  |  Services  |  Search  |  Contact Us  
Planning
 

Heritage Preservation for the Future

By: Matthew D. Schrag, Elaine G. Staab,
Bobbi Jo Burnett, and Mary B. La Lone

 

 

INTRODUCTION

Montgomery County is presented with an important opportunity to preserve and call attention to its coal mining heritage through the creation of a heritage park at Merrimac, the former site of one of the largest mines and mining communities in the region. This heritage park will be the first of its kind in Montgomery County and will provide many people an opportunity to view and study a portion of history that was so vital to the area. The Huckleberry Trail laid the "tracks" for the advent of this park, and community support has shown that the current trend of interest in a Coal Mining Heritage Park will continue.

The landscape of the region has changed over time from a predominantly rural setting of farms and coal mining communities, to an urbanizing setting with highways and shopping malls criss-crossing the region. With endeavors to progress into the 21st Century, the history that put Montgomery County on the map is vanishing more and more with each passing year. With definite ties as far back as the Civil War, and most likely the Revolutionary War, coal mining in the New River Valley has a rich history that needs to be told. The park will commemorate and present the history of coal mining throughout the entire county and New River Valley. Although situated at Merrimac, the park will give recognition to all of the mines and mining communities in the region.

The county has witnessed a growing interest in preserving and commemorating its coal mining history (as described in Chapter 1). Following a series of Roanoke Times articles in 1994 on the region's mining history (Freis 1994a-d), the families of former miners came together to form the Coal Mining Heritage Association of Montgomery County. In its first year, the CMHA built a commemorative monument and worked with the county Board of Supervisors to establish an annual Coal Mining Heritage Day. Momentum for mining heritage preservation has been growing since then. As part of this heritage effort, Dr. La Lone and Radford University students worked with the CMHA to create a two-volume record of mining family oral histories (La Lone 1997, 1998, 1999). The work from that oral history project provides extensive documentation of the region's mining life that can form the basis for signage, exhibits, and other heritage-based educational activities. Our work with the Montgomery County Planning Office and the CMHA on this park project is a logical "applied" extension of the heritage preservation effort. The CMHA also played a strong role in efforts to draft the text for signage for the Huckleberry Trail (Huckleberry Trail Exhibit Design Project 1996). The drafts of those signs, written with community input, are incorporated into our signage ideas discussed below. The Montgomery County families of the CMHA form a strong constituent for the development of a mining heritage park. They will provide the heritage knowledge and community energy for this park. They are joined by others with an interest in learning about and teaching about the region's heritage -- area school teachers, other heritage groups, residents of the Merrimac community, and many interested trail users.

The research team derived many of its heritage ideas for the park from former mining families and other county citizens. Through the community meetings held at Merrimac in October 1999 and the surveys mailed to residents, we collected ideas from the community on how best to present this extraordinary history for future generations to understand. Many members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association helped with ideas and information. Interviews with Fred Lawson, Alex Linkous, Lee Linkous, Sam Huff, Hazel Hodge, Esther Jones, and Jimmie Price provided much of the information on mining and family life used in this chapter. Additional information came from the interviews in Appalachian Mining Memories and Coal Mining Lives (La Lone 1997, 1998), and from Merrimac Mines (Proco 1994).

Interest in having heritage features in the Merrimac park is quite strong. In the survey responses, two-thirds of the respondents indicated that they wanted historical signs. Two-thirds also indicated their desire to see a mining museum as part of the park. The survey written responses, and the interests and wishes elicited from people during community meetings, also demonstrate that people have extensive interest in making mining heritage a featured theme at the park (see the Appendices for this community input).

We combined the ideas generated from the community with our own research of relatively small-sized interpretive history parks (Explore Park and the Beckley Exhibition Coal Mine), to arrive at a set of potential ideas for heritage-based exhibition and education at the Coal Mining Heritage Park. Our ideas for preserving the coal mining heritage range from simple informative signposts to a reconstructed miner’s house displayed in all its glory as it once stood many years ago. The following pages will give the reader a good overview of what we envision for an integrated heritage park. We provide extensive discussion of potential heritage signs and their placement in the park, walking trails developed for heritage learning, construction of historic buildings, and construction of a museum/visitors center. A section on phasing has been included following the detailed descriptions to give an idea of what should occur and when. This chapter will attempt to synthesize these ideas into a working model for the heritage-based aspects of the park at Merrimac.

SIGNAGE

Signs will be an integral part of portraying the history to the park visitors. During the initial phases of park planning and construction, a few signs (as well as some other types of development addressed in other chapters) will be needed to let the public know that the park is progressing and not just being put on the back burner. Several positive consequences will emerge from adding just a few of these signs as soon as possible. One, the public will begin learning about the heritage that made this area what it is. Two, signage will generate interest in the park even more so than it is now. Those who do not know about the history will be exposed to it and hopefully will be inspired to learn more. Three, signage is a relatively low-cost and effective way to start park development, which will keep initial county expenditure to a minimum.

This section presents some ideas for heritage signs and their placement within the park. Figure 3.1 is a map of the park showing the locations of these signs.

Several of the signs proposed here were written by a community group of miners and researchers organized to develop signs for the Huckleberry Trail as part of the 1996 Huckleberry Trail Exhibit Design Project funded by a grant from the Virginia Foundation for the Humanities. These signs will be referenced below an asterisk and the citation "Huckleberry Trail Design Project." Three of these signs have been mocked up and presented in this chapter to give a visual idea of what the signs could look like. Some minor modifications have been made with regards to the verbiage of these signs.

There should be signs welcoming both the people enjoying the Huckleberry Trail and those specifically visiting to enjoy the park. These signs should be placed at the eastern and western entrances to the park and the park entrance at the parking lot access trail. A title needs to be centered at the top as in the following example.

Also at the park entrance at Merrimac Road, during the initial phases of the project, a sign should provide the current Huckleberry Trail users with the basic plans for the park. A sign should inform them that work on the site has started and tell them of some of the features to be incorporated over time. Something simple will work well to inform people of the upcoming plans as well as offer a means to contact someone for more information or to donate to the project. This sign should also provide a space where upcoming events in the park, volunteer days, funding needs, or successes could be posted and changed as needed. This will give people up-to-date information about what is happening and what is needed in the park.

After entering the park, additional signs would provide heritage information. As you continue walking down the Huckleberry Trail, a sign should be placed on the right hand side of the trail facing what was known as Bunker Hill. Bunker Hill is where the mining company built a number of company houses for miners and their families. This sign will give information to the reader about the area of Merrimac where many of the mining families lived -- where they grew crops, played, laughed, and visited with one another. The sign that should be placed here will inform the visitor of some of the history of Bunker Hill and the daily lives of mining families. In addition to text, we recommend that the sign show photos of an actual Merrimac miner's house (e.g. Robert Lawson's house; see Figure 3.6 below).

The county does not presently own most of Bunker Hill. Currently, only two of the sixteen Bunker Hill house sites are on county land. It is recommended that this land be purchased in its entirety to further preserve the historic integrity of the landscape.

Bunker Hill's history may date back to the Civil War. Bunker Hill is thought to be the site of the Confederate colliery located at Merrimac during the Civil War. The colliery is presumed to be located on Bunker Hill based on information given on the Confederate government map of Montgomery County by Lt. Dwight drafted in 1864. The civil war heritage could provide the subject for a second sign at this location. Associated with this sign would be pictures from the Civil War and the 1864 map by Lt. Dwight or Jeremy Francis Gilmer’s Confederate Engineer Map showing the location of the colliery and other structures of military importance.

Further down the trail, prior to reaching the Tipple Heritage Area, it is recommended that another sign be placed on the left side of the trail informing the reader of the early history of mining in Merrimac. Associated on the sign should be appropriate pictures about the early mining history: a photograph of families hauling coal in wagons for the first paragraph and a picture of the Merrimac for the second paragraph.

Continuing on the Huckleberry Trail will bring you to the central industrial area surrounding the tipple. This was the central focus of mining after the Civil War. A multitude of structures existed here each providing its specific functioning to the overall mining operation. We have labeled this area of the park the "Tipple Heritage Area." This area's main focus will be heritage preservation by presenting the visitor with an array of signs and artifacts to view and examine. This area seems to be a natural gathering point for former miners as well as some of the Huckleberry Trail users. It is directly off of the Huckleberry Trail, is a flat, open area, and has several structural pieces of historic value still remaining. The "Tipple Heritage Area" is a logical focal point during the initial stages of the park.

One of the major features for this area would be signage. We envision four signs at the Tipple Heritage Area, which we have described in more detail below. Several of the larger kiosk-style signs of the park should be located here. One should be a diagram and map of the New River Valley area highlighting all of the mines in the region. It is important to highlight all of the mines in the NRV for several reasons. First, although the park is located at Merrimac, it is intended to be a countywide and regional coal mining park. We need to give recognition to all of the miners and their families that worked and lived here in the NRV and elsewhere in southwest Virginia. All need to feel welcome and not left out. Second, there were so many mines in the area and they all functioned together as a composite economic base for the region. This region would not be what it is today had it not been for all of the mines, not just Merrimac. Merrimac is simply a representative example of the larger picture.

We recommend that this sign feature three maps. The first map should name and identify each of the mines in the NRV with certain roads and other features in order to identify the mines’ locations in reference to commonly known landmarks. This map could be made in conjunction with the research that Jimmy Lee Price has conducted and gathered about mining in the New River Valley. He has researched the locations of many of these mines. Also on this sign should be a topographic map of Merrimac, circa 1937, identifying all of the mining structures by name. This map has already been drafted by Scott Kennedy, a former graduate student at Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, in conjunction with former miner Fred Lawson and the Coal Mining Heritage Association (See Figure 3.2). Below this should be a final map depicting the park, as it will be when completed, with all of the other trails, signs, and other features noted (the map of the park in Figure 2.1 in Chapter 2). This entire sign would only require a title and brief description of what it shows. A possible title might be ‘Coal Mining in the New River Valley’. Under the regional map should be a caption that reads ‘Regional Map Showing All Mining Operations in the New River Valley’. Under the Merrimac map should be ‘Map of 1937 Merrimac Community Depicting All Structures’. Under the park map should be a caption that reads "Coal Mining Heritage Park Today."

Next to this sign should be another sign with several photographs to show people actual pictures of what mining was like. One of the photos should be one of the more striking photographs -- a group of miners standing in a line in front of the tipple with the caption ‘A group of miners and mine officials at the tipple, 1922’ (see Figure 3.3).

Figure 3.3 A group of miners and mine officials at the tipple, 1922.

The other photograph should be an overview shot of the industrial site, with each structure given a number and its corresponding title below the photo. Also on the photo should be a ‘You Are Here’ arrow to give the viewer a visual cue as to what the area looked like that he/she is standing on.

Attached to this sign should be a place for pamphlets. These pamphlets would be something that those enjoying the park could carry around with them and would give them another map of the park with all of its activities expressed on it in more detail. Also in the pamphlet should be the numerically coded mining structures with descriptions of what they were used for. The numbered photograph and pamphlets should correspond to and be used in conjunction with numbered posts placed at each of the identified industrial sites (discussed later).

By walking the trails throughout the park the visitor can match the numbered posts with the numbered descriptions in the pamphlet to identify historic sites and learn about what went on at the place that they are standing. By doing so, the visitor gets a sense of reality to the area. It gives it a little more life and also reduces cost to the county and visual clutter to the visitor by reducing the number of larger informational signs dotting the landscape.

Another focus of the ‘Tipple Heritage Area’ should be the ‘Heritage Bridge’. This would be a covered structure spanning the two remaining concrete foundations that straddle Lick Creek. It would provide two other kiosk style signs that could present a pictorial collage of coal mining with captions and other relevant park information.

Another feature at this site could be listening boxes that provide recorded interviews with some of the members of the mining families that give an oral discussion about work and activities at the site of the tipple. This provides the visitor with more than just visual stimulation. They would be able to hear the depth of the voices and stories told.

The ‘Heritage Bridge’ would also provide one of the bridges over Lick Creek connecting the north and south sides of the park. This junction will provide access to the mineshaft, low-impact trails on the south side, and the recreation area and pavilion. Concern should be taken with how this structure is constructed so as to maintain a sense of heritage. One might consider using construction techniques utilized during the mining days with assistance from community groups or other volunteers. It needs to look like it belonged at the site when the mines were in operation.

Also at the ‘Tipple Heritage Area’ near the remaining concrete foundation associated with the tipple, should be a sign about the tipple itself. The background photograph described in the text below is the oldest photograph taken of the industrial area. The photograph appears in Garland Proco’s book (pages 32-33) and can be obtained through the publication Mineral Resources of Virginia for use on the sign. The suggested text for the sign "Loading the Cars: The Tipple at the Merrimac Mine" follows.

Another sign in the ‘Tipple Heritage Area’ would describe the mining operation and be located in front of an exhibit of a pair of the iron coal cars used in mining operations. The Coal Mining Heritage Association of Montgomery County has indicated that it might be able to arrange for the donation of the coal cars for this exhibit. In the exhibit, the cars would rest on the tracks that they would have ridden on and be associated with the hoist mechanism used to haul the cars from the mine that is already on site. These artifacts could be arranged to look like the hoist is hauling the cars. A mockup of this sign has already been made as part of the Huckleberry Trail Design Project (see Figure 3.4).

 

Figure 3.4 Sample mockup of the "Ten Tons Per Day" sign created by

the Huckleberry Trail Design Project.

 

Continuing down the Huckleberry Trail towards the west, leaving the ‘Tipple Heritage Area’, the visitor will come upon another sign located just off of the Huckleberry Trail. This sign would describe the Huckleberry Railroad’s association with the mining operations at Merrimac. This sign should also be associated with a set of railroad tracks and railroad ties that should be laid in front of the sign so that the person who is reading the sign would be standing on the tracks.

Continuing down the Huckleberry, the visitor will arrive at the site for our replicated miner’s house (discussed later in this chapter). There should be a sign at this site about mining life and the houses associated with it. This sign should have a small map of the Merrimac area highlighting the houses and several pictures of them as well as activities that went on around the house.

Just a few yards down the trail from the house should be a sign discussing the other non-residential, non-industrial structures such as the commissary and hotel. The sign would be located near the actual site of these buildings. Associated on this sign should be pictures of each of the mentioned building as well as a picture of Merrimac scrip.

The signage associated with this park will be an integral and necessary aspect of it. They will educate and inform park visitors who may or may not already know about the region’s history. However, along with the educational signs should be trails designed to take people on a walking tour of the historic landscape. These trails will allow visitors to explore the area and view many of the historic sites as they are today. The following section briefly discusses these trails with regards to the historic applications but will be discussed at length in Chapter 3.

TRAILS AND RELATED HERITAGE FEATURES

Located in the park should also be a network of ADA accessible and low-impact trails that will take the visitor on a tour of the historical sites not located on or near the Huckleberry Trail. These trails will be discussed in much more detail in Chapter 5. This section discusses the historical need for their construction. These trails are what will take the visitor "off the beaten path" and give them an opportunity to see some of the smaller sites in the area. While smaller and maybe less impressive than the tipple and the hotel and the commissary, these sites played an integral role in the functioning of the mines and the lives of the people.

One set of trails, the Drift Mouth Trail and the Mule Trail, would take the visitor on a tour of the floodplain on the south side of the Huckleberry Trail. These trails would highlight the sites that were part of the mine's industrial complex: the fan house, powder/dynamite building, tipple, mine opening, old washhouse, shops (blacksmith, sawmill), lamp house, boiler building, wash/change house, and the mule barn. Each of these sites, with the exception of the mine opening, should be marked by one of the numbered posts that corresponds with the pamphlet descriptions. The mine opening should have an additional informational sign associated with it. This sign, "All in a Day's Work," has been mocked up as part of the Huckleberry Trail Design Project (see Figure 3.5). It should be located at the mouth of the mine.

Figure 3.5 Sample mockup of the "All in a Day’s Work" sign created by

the Huckleberry Trail Design Project.

Located with this sign should be a listening station. This would have changeable tapes that play the voices of former miners, in their own words, speaking about working in the mine and other industrial sounds of interest. These could be changed bi-annually to continue people’s interest.

Another side trail, the Miner's House Trail, would break from the Huckleberry Trail near the commissary (and future site of a Reconstructed Miner's House) to take the visitor up the northwest slope to the ruins of one of the actual former houses (see Figure 3.1), which should also be marked with a numbered post. The archaeological destination will highlight one of the structures as it is today. A residence has collapsed in on itself, but is well enough preserved to be a site of much archaeological interest. This site would be featured as an archaeological learning exhibit, providing an opportunity to teach people (both children and adults) about archaeology and how to protect these sites. The archaeological exhibit area would serve as a tool for discussing archaeological preservation and interpretation, and should have explanatory signage. This site holds information relating to the social integration of the Merrimac community as well as typical household routines and a host of other information. Since the site needs to be protected from being destroyed by people walking through it, a walkway might be constructed around the site giving people an opportunity to see the site with minimal disturbance. Behind the house, markers could indicate where the residential garden and outbuildings were located. A barrier of natural brush could be erected around the site to keep visitors within the exhibit area, and prevent them from disturbing other areas of potential archaeological value.

The Bunker Hill Trail will also climb the northern slope, going from the Tipple Heritage Area up past the hoist houses, and will ascend toward a scenic overlook. Visitors will be able to look out over the whole industrial site, and signage will help them identify features in the industrial setting below. Other signage will point out the location of some of the houses on Bunker Hill (at present, most of those sites lie outside the park boundaries, but the visitor can view Bunker Hill from the overlook).

The trails that will provide access to the historic sites are an essential aspect of the park. They will give people the opportunity to see the historic landscape as it stands today. They will be immersed in nature and will be able to absorb the history of the land to ponder what once was and what might be in the future. But, the park needs more than trails to complete this thought for the visitors. Other aspects of the park should include reconstructed buildings and a museum. These additions to the park will give the visitors a full and as-complete-as-possible picture of mining life in the New River Valley. They will be able to see what things really looked like.

REPLICATED MINER’S HOUSE

After trails and heritage signs have been established at the park, we recommend the next step be to construct a replicated miner’s house. We recommend constructing a replicated house as a first step, rather than reconstructing an authentic building. One reason is concern for the building’s security against vandalism. Of course, we highly recommend that a high quality security system be installed at the building, as well as throughout the park, to prevent vandalism (see Chapter 4 for a discussion of security recommendations). However, should vandalism occur to a replicated building, it would be less of a heritage loss than if it were an authentic structure and the effects on future plans to develop the park would be less devastating. Instead, it would be best if the first structure to be built were a replicated model of a miner’s house.

The construction of a replica miner’s house would provide an exciting exhibit portraying the mining heritage, and could be a site for interpretive reenactment of the mining lifestyle. This addition to the park would be a big "plus" in that it would spark public interest for the park. It would serve as a drawing feature, and a focus for heritage education, much like the exhibits at heritage parks such as Explore Park and the Beckley Exhibition Coal Mine. The construction of the miner’s house could be undertaken as a joint effort between the county and community, thus giving the community a vested interest in the development of the park. Later, with continuing support and community involvement, other heritage structures could be added to the park

In its heyday, when the Merrimac Mine was in operation, a number of miner’s houses surrounded the mine. Similarly, miner’s houses were located near mines throughout the New River Valley. New River Valley mining families can serve as valuable resources, providing the knowledge about house construction and layout that would enable a replica miner’s house to be built and furnished. With the help of some of the members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association, we will describe two houses from the New River Valley that might serve as models to replicate a miner’s house at the Merrimac park.

The first house is described by Merrimac miner Fred Lawson. It is the house at Merrimac in which his brother, Robert Lawson, grew up. This house was originally located at the base of Bunker Hill. It is identified as feature number 29 on the historic map of Merrimac, circa 1937, drawn by Scott Kennedy and Fred Lawson. Below is a description of this house.


It was a T-shaped four-room house. The kitchen was through the front door, a living room was located in the middle, and 2 bedrooms were in the back. A porch ran along the front of the house. Eight to ten-foot boards raised it up in the front and in the back it sat on a hill, which was Bunker Hill

(Lawson 10/12/99).

Figure 3.6 Photo of Merrimac miner’s house (feature number 29). Courtesy of Fred Lawson.

The second coal miner’s house that could serve as a model is one from the Coal Bank Hollow section of Montgomery County. This house was still standing until 1996, when the Coal Mining Heritage Association saved it from being burnt down by having it dismantled and stored. The house is described below by Hazel Hodge. She grew up in this house and gives a very clear description. Again, this information could be used in replicating a miner’s house for the Coal Mining Heritage Park.

Figure 3.7 Photo of the "little brown house" described above;
courtesy of Hazel Hodge

 

It was called the "little brown house" and was located on Coal Bank Hollow Road on Brush Mountain. It was a simple three-room house where 7 people lived. The 3 rooms were a kitchen, a living room/bedroom, and another bedroom. The kitchen contained a coal and wood cook stove, a table with benches, a side table, a bucket with a dipper, old- timey kitchen cabinets, and a round washing tub. The living room/ bedroom had a baby bed, a couch that was also a bed, straight-backchairs, a rocking chair, and a pot-bellied stove. The other bedroom had a big bed, a half bed, hooks to hang clothes on, and a dresser. All the room were lighted by kerosene lamps. It was a simple house, the house of a coal miner. It was designed by a system known as "tongue and groove", which is one-inch boards hooked together. Outside was a smokehouse and an out house. There was also a small garden where vegetables were grown and a pen where they raised hogs (Hodge 10/18/99).

 

The best location for a replicated miners house at Merrimac would be next to the Huckleberry Trail, near where the commissary once stood. (See the map of the park conceptual plan in Chapter 2.) We believe this is a good location for three reasons. One important reason is its accessibility by being located right on the Huckleberry Trail. As trail users passing through the park, this would provide an interesting stopping point, or a destination in and of itself. The second reason is security, since this is an open and visible area through which trail users frequently pass. A third reason, is that it provides a heritage feature at the west end of the park, something to balance with the Bunker Hill area on the east end and the Tipple Area in the middle of the park. Visitors and trail users can be drawn along the full length of the Huckleberry Trail within the park boundaries, learning about the mining heritage along the way.

GARDEN

Many people have also suggested designing a garden next to the house. In the mining village nearly everyone had a garden plot where they grew their own fruits and vegetables. Gardening was an important part of their culture. Esther Jones, who tended to her garden at Wake Forest describes gardening.

We grew tomatoes, beans, onions, peppers, corn, peas, carrots,

and any vegetable you can think of. We used a horse and plow. We

would plow it and then had to brake up the clots. We also had

grapes, peaches, plums, cherries, and apples. People would come by

and we would sell it to them. We canned about 200 jars a year

( Jones 11/15/99).

STRUCTURES SURROUNDING THE HOUSE

Esther Jones also listed other structures that surrounded the house. These include:

- smokehouse - woodhouse

- corn crib - outhouse

- coal house - shed

- barn

Perhaps one or two of these structures such as the smoke house and an outhouse could be made next to the garden. After all, many of these things were utilized by a miner and his family and would help to portray their lives.

FURNISHING THE HOUSE

In regards to the house itself, another possibility is that we furnish the inside. Then, visitors would be able to see what a coal miner’s house contained and understand what it was like to live in the mines. Several members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association are willing to donate items to furnish a house. Here is a list of a few of the things the Association has to offer.

- wood stove - old-timey kitchen cabinets

- curtains - place cloths and place settings

- quilts - chairs

- dishes - washtub

- sheets - sewing table and machine

- washboards - iron

- canning funnel - mason jars to store fruits and vegetables

- potato masher - eggbeater

- dinner bell - butter printer and paddle

- strainer and crock - dresses and aprons

Figures 3.8 and 3.9 are two photographs of the inside of a coal miner’s house that were taken at the Coal Miners Exhibition in Beckley, West Virginia. This gives you an idea of what a furnished coal miner’s house looks like. The woman pictured in Figure 3.9 was a coal miner’s wife and serves as a guide inside the house. Many women who are members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association such as Esther Jones or Hazel Hodge, just to name a few, would be happy to do this. Besides educating the public on coal mining, a volunteer inside would help to monitor and protect the building.

Figure 3.8 The furnished inside of a miner’s house, Exhibition Coal Mine,
Beckley, West Virginia.

Figure 3.9 The furnished inside of a miner’s house, Exhibition Coal Mine,
Beckley, West Virginia.

 

MUSEUM/VISITORS CENTER

After a coal miner’s house is built and the park is underway we recommend

creating a combined Museum and Visitors Center. A mining museum would provide an excellent way to educate the public about coal mining heritage. Several members of the community and Coal Mining Heritage Association have expressed an interest in a museum. The building of a mining museum at the park would provide an excellent center of activity for preserving an important part of the New River Valley’s heritage. We recommend that this be undertaken as a joint venture between the county and the mining heritage association. Other groups, including schools, universities, churches, and other regional history associations might also be drawn into a partnership to build and maintain activities at the museum. A museum would serve the county as a wonderful heritage preservation and heritage educational facility, as well as provide a focal point for the park in the form of a visitors center. The museum could house artifacts, photos, videos, tapes, and books. Museum activities could include exhibits, interpretive living history events, and educational outreach programs. Elementary and high school teachers could bring their classes, and visitors could learn about coal mining and its importance to this region of Virginia.

The community and students are interested in learning about coal mining. Several miners have visited local schools to share information on coal mining with students and received excellent feedback. Mrs. Wheeler who teaches a fourth grade class at Kipps Elementary says, "Our children live in the area and coal mining is an important part of their heritage. Standards of Learning (SOL) requires us to teach about products of southwest Virginia which includes coal mining. When the coal miners visit they tell delightful stories and give kids a chance to learn how to do things hands on with some of their tools. It would be wonderful to have a museum where things were permanently displayed. That would be a field trip for us." Many other teachers have similar feelings about educating their students on coal mining and incorporating it into their curriculum.

The principal of Price's Fork Elementary, Dolly Cottrill, also comments that with a museum, "The children will learn to respect the past lifeways of their parents and great grandparents." Currently the children at Price's Fork Elementary visit the Coal Mining Exhibition in Beckley, West Virginia. Beth McDonald, a teacher at Price's Fork Elementary School would like the field trip to hit closer to home. She says, "There isn't

any reason why the children shouldn't visit a local coal mine. They learn about the local coal mining business yet they have to travel to West Virginia to experience it in real life." Many others feel that having a heritage coal mining museum in the area would be a wonderful resource.

Several members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association who worked or lived in the mines visit schools to teach children about coal mining. Fred Lawson who has presented at several schools says, "Kids are very curious about the process of mining and tools used. They ask a lot of inquisitive questions. Then, after we leave they usually send us thank you cards with their individual interests and sometimes drawings of the coal mines, the way they see them." Dana Acres who has presented at the Roanoke Transportation Museum, Roanoke Art Museum, and Explore Park Symposiums has gotten similar responses from her audiences. Children and groups of all ages are interested in hearing her stories, which surround real events, adventures, and tragedies, that occurred growing up, and living in the mines. She has been invited to appear before many groups and has gotten great support for her efforts. She believes, like others, that there should be a coal miner’s museum where information can be permanently displayed. After all, she says, "the oral tradition and legends on coal mining which have been passed down from one generation to the next will not last forever and they should be stored in a museum or place where they cannot be forgotten."

The best place to locate the museum is at the entrance to the park beside the parking lot. There are several reasons for this location. One is that people may be visiting the park only to see the museum, and in order to reduce traffic in other parts of the park it should be situated at the entrance. Secondly, several visitors may include small children or handicapped visitors who are not be able to travel far to get to the museum. For their convenience and safety this would be the best location. Last and most importantly, keeping the museum at the entrance, in a visible and public area, reduces the risk of vandalism. To further reduce the risk of vandalism a security system should be considered. A security system could cost up to $4,800 dollars, however the cost of rebuilding a museum and replacing all the information lost is far more expensive. Many people are only willing to donate items to the museum if they know the building will be secure.

Members of the community and Coal Mining Heritage Association are willing to help support a museum. Several miners have expressed an interest in staffing the museum themselves. What a wonderful resource it would be to have miners sharing their information and stories on coal mining with the public. Visitors would be able to learn about coal mining, first hand, from those who have experienced it.

As far as what to put inside the museum, many former coal miners and members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association have enough things to fill five museums or more. If such a museum were to be built by the county in association with the Coal Mining Heritage Association, they would willingly contribute pictures, maps, clothing, tools, household items, and much more. They would be proud to see items of their heritage displayed. We took an inventory of these items. Ideas for exhibits were generated from members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association, input from local teachers and schools, as well as observation of exhibits at the Exhibition Coal Mine in Beckley, West Virginia and exhibits at the Roanoke Museum of Transportation for its 1999 annual Coal Miner’s Day (set up in conjunction with the Coal Mining Heritage Association). Below, we have listed a number of potential exhibits for a museum at the Coal Mining Heritage Park.

EXHIBITS

Mining Tools

A miner worked with various tools inside the mine. Many of these tools should be displayed. Below is a list of many of these tools along with photographs.

Mining pick- a pointed metal tool used to loosen coal

Augurs- a drill used to design holes for loading dynamite

Breastplate- metal that attached to the augur and provided pressure while drilling into the mine seam

Tamping Bar- long metal bar; one end was first used to clean debris from fuse and then the other notched end was used to load dynamite

Dynamite and exploders-inserted into the mine wall to loosen coal

Powder Bag- leather bag that carried dynamite and exploders

Figure 3.10 Tools in a case at Coal Mining Exhibition Mine in Beckley, West Virginia.

Figure 3.11 Powder bag with dynamite and exploders. Photo courtesy of Fred Lawson.

Clothing

A manikin could be displayed in miner's gear. In Figure 3.12, a manikin miner is wearing jean overalls, a jacket, high top shoes, a safety hat with a light, and a battery attached around a belt at the waist. He is holding a lunch pail and is standing in

a pile of coal (field notes at Roanoke Museum of Transportation 11/6/99)

Figure 3.12 Manikin wearing a miner’s clothing, Roanoke Museum of Transportation.

Lights In The Mines

Other important tools that deserve their own display are lights. A miner used carbide and later electrical lights to light his workspace.

Carbide lights- light produced from carbide gas that fit on a safety hat

Carbide flask- metal canteen miner carried carbide in

Carbide cans- commercial package carbide fluid was sold in

Electrical lights-replaced carbide lights in early 1900’s, fit on the safety hat and charged from a battery.

Belt- carried battery attached to electrical light

Safety hat- hard hat that protected a miner from rock falls and held a carbide or electrical light

Kerosene light- light created with a rag and kerosene in a bottle, only used in particular tunnel mines

Figure 3.13 Safety lights. Photo courtesy of Fred Lawson.

 

Safety In The Mines

The air within the mines was constantly checked for increasing levels of methane gas that could lead to a fire or explosion. A few important tools helped to maintain safety.

Air Gauge- metal speedometer that fire boss used to measure air pressure and check air flow within mines

Safety lamp- gas fueled metal lamp used to detect methane in the mines, if the light flickered or went out methane was present

Rescue Kit- plastic face nozzle attached to an oxygen tank that a miner could use in the event that he was trapped in the mines. Could last him up to 30 minutes.

Figure 3.14 Safety gear. Photo courtesy of Fred Lawson.

Other Items Used By Miners

Several other items were used by a miner but were not directly related to the process of mining. However, these things were a necessity to miners.

Lunch Pail- metal bucket with 3 components: first for a sandwich, second for a desert, and third held a quart of water to sustain a miner for several hours in the event that he was trapped in the mine.

Wash Tub- metal bucket used to hold water and wash with in the washhouse following a day of work in the mine

Scrip- a form of currency at the mines that came in the form of paper or coins and could only be spent at the company store. Some script was equivalent to dollars and cents while others were more specific in value and could be exchanged for items such as dynamite, tools, or coal.

Household Items

Women and children who lived at the mines also participated in a number of activities. In order to understand their role and life at the coal mines many people have suggested featuring a display with a few of the household items

Washboard- wooden board used to scrub clothes

Sewing machine or treadle-used to make clothing and bedding

Iron- metal heated on a wood stove to straighten clothing

Curtains, table setting, sheets, and quilts- colorful, sometimes made from empty cotton feed sacks

Dresses and bonnets- also made from feed sacks

Strainer and crock- fine screen and porcelain container that milk was strained and then stored in

Butter printer and paddle-wooden implements used to make butter

Canning funnel and mason jars-used to store vegetables and fruits from the garden

Potato masher and egg beater- metal; old-fashioned kitchen tools

 

Figure 3.15 Household items on a quilt. Photo courtesy of Esther Jones.

Figure 3.16 Washboard, Roanoke Museum of Transportation

 

Photographs

There are also numerous photo collections in the possession of Fred Lawson, Kenneth McCoy, Jimmy Price and many other miners, as well as located in the Special Collections at the Virginia Tech Library. Photos display workers lined up to enter the mine, workers constructing the tipple, the mine supervisors, and miners and family members together. These photographs could all be displayed on the walls of the museum, providing an informative visual depiction of the mining way of life. After all, have you ever heard the saying "each picture speaks a thousand words?"

Videos

There are two great videos that illustrate mining life in the New River Valley. One is "Hard Times and Rich Memories," a film produced by Robert Freis, Jimmy Price, and Shawna Scott. The film documents peoples’ memories of the mining life using numerous excerpts from videotaped oral history interviews. It covers the history, working conditions, family life, and some of the tragedies that occurred in the New River Valley mines. The second video was produced by Dudley Scott, a former fire boss for one of the New River Valley mines. This video also explores some of the hardships of life at the mines, with numerous interviews and photographs. Each video is an hour long. A room in the museum could be designated to showing videos, providing a dynamic look into mining life to complement the exhibits on display.

A MINING HERITAGE ARCHIVE FOR BOOKS, DOCUMENTATION, AND ORAL HISTORIES

The Coal Mining Heritage Association is concerned that documentation about the region’s mines needs to be collected and preserved for heritage education. One room in the museum could function as an archive, housing books, historical documentation on the region’s mines and mining life, and oral history collections. Mining families have a wealth of photos and personal records which would be valuable for helping us document the region’s mining heritage, but the families want to be assured that their records will be housed in a safe location and be accessible for educational learning. The Coal Mining Heritage Association does not currently have a place to house such a collection. In addition to providing a central visitors center focus for the park, a museum at Montgomery County’s Coal Mining Heritage Park would be a logical place to establish a regional coal mining archive.

Children’s Corner

A number of people at our community meetings recommended having a small children's corner in the museum where workshops and games for kids could be set-up. Some of these games would help to teach the children in an exciting way. For example a train set and miniature mining structures could be displayed like they are below in Figure 3.17.

Figure 3.17 Miniature train and mining structures, set up at the
Roanoke Museum of Transportation

Stories about coal mining could be played by cassette. At several museums this method has worked with headphones or an intercom. Picture books should also be available. Children can then page through and see some of the scenes at the mines. Games played by children at the mines were simple games such as marbles and dominos. Members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association who have memories growing up in the mines suggest these games are set-up. All of these games and resources together will help children to learn about coal mining heritage at their own level.

The museum will be a central information and education source at the coal mining heritage park. It will educate people on the facets of a coal mining community. This includes information on the lifeways of men, women, and children. Information about the community and actual process of coal mining will be displayed. The visitors can rely on the museum to exhibit photographs, maps, and information that detail life in the New River Valley coal mines.

OTHER HERITAGE STUCTURES

After the museum is built a few of the structures that were formerly at Merrimac should be reconstructed. Presently, there are no standing structures at Merrimac. There are the remains of a few foundations but buildings that once existed have now deteriorated. It is hard to imagine that an entire coal mining village once stood at Merrimac. In reconstructing a few of the structures visitors will be able to understand and see what a coal mining village might have appeared like. Members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association have made a number of recommendations on which buildings best represented the mining community.

Commissary

One central focus at the village was the commissary or company store. (See number 6 on the historic map of Merrimac, circa 1937, drawn by Scott Kennedy and Fred Lawson; see Figure 3.2.) A family went to the commissary on almost a daily basis to purchase food and other important items. The commissary could be reconstructed along with the post office and superintendents office as it once was. According to former Merrimac miner Fred Lawson, the building had the following appearance:

Figure 3.18 Layout of the commissary, based on the description of Fred Lawson.

A long counter stretched along the front of the store. Behind the counter was where all items to be sold were kept. In the center of the room was a cage made out of chicken wire where suits were kept. Attached to the commissary were other important rooms. There was a flour room where bags of flour were stored. There was a feed room where 100-pound sacks of feed for hogs or cows were kept. In the back of the building were general offices where about 6 people worked in a room behind a desk doing engineer type work. In the back right corner of the building was a big room where the superintendent worked. Then back in the left corner was the post office. There were small boxes and a desk where the postmaster would sit. A porch wrapped around the outside of the building and the train line ran right beside it. All the mail, goods from the commissary, feed, and over all supplies would be dropped on the porch from the train ( Lawson 10/12/99).

Combined Shops

Another important building was the combined shops. (See numbers 20 and 20A on the historic map of Merrimac, circa 1937, drawn by Scott Kennedy and Fred Lawson; see Figure 3.2.) This should not be confused with the company store. Things were not sold here instead, a number of people worked for the mines here. There was a blacksmith shop, a car shop, a sawmill, and a light house. These buildings were adjoined together.

Figure 3.19 Layout of the combined shops, based on the description of Fred Lawson.

The car shop is where they would bring the coal cars that had been damaged. They were also built there. The cars had to be built very sturdy. They were built with a metal frame, wooden side boards, and 4 wheels. They kept all sorts of machinery in the car shop. Then the blacksmith shop had a big table where tools would be laid out to be repaired. They used a forge and an anvil which were used sort of like a hammer to shape things. You sharpened picks and augurs and made parts to be used on the coal cars. The light house had racks for the electric lights to be plugged in. The miner would bring his light in and it would recharge over night. Lastly, the sawmill is where they dumped timber to be sawed. The saw mill was connected to the rest of the building with a roof but there were no walls, it was left open (Lawson 10/12/99).

Storage Buildings

There are a number of other small buildings that a miner visited on his daily routine. According to former Merrimac miner Fred Lawson at the start of the day a miner first went to the wash house to change his clothes (number 22 on the historic map of Merrimac, circa 1937, drawn by Scott Kennedy and Fred Lawson; see Figure 3.2), then to the lamp house to get his lamp (number 20A on the 1937 map), next to the powder room to get his dynamite and explosives (number 14 on the 1937 map), and last to the mule barn only if he was a mule driver (number 23 on the 1937 map). It would be interesting if we could re-create this process of events that went on by rebuilding the wash house, light house, powder house, and mule barn. These were not great big structures and certainly would not take as much effort or be as costly as reconstructing some of the other buildings.

The washhouse consisted of a cement floor with a drain. A pot-bellied stove sat in the center of the room and cabinets were on the side. A miner would come to the washhouse to get his clothes in the morning and then return to wash himself in a wash tub after a day of work in the mine. At the lamp house a miner would pick up his lamp that had been recharging in the room over night. It was basically a room with shelves where miners stored their lamps. Next is the powder and dynamite building where a miner went to buy his dynamite and explosives in the morning. Lastly was the mule barn. A mule driver would come here to harness his mule up before proceeding to work. There were 15-20 stalls in the barn and bails of hay were stacked in the loft. Outside was a fenced area where the mules could roam (Lawson 10/12/99).

Tipple

The tipple and hoist house were paramount to running the mine (see number

15 on the historic map of Merrimac, circa 1937, drawn by Scott Kennedy and Fred Lawson; see Figure 3.2). Coal was processed and sorted at the tipple before it was loaded on to the train. In reconstructing these buildings people would be able to understand how the process of mining coal actually worked. It was an ingenious system that was all done by machine. Below is a description of the tipple and how it worked.

Figure 3.20 Tipple during mining operation.

Figure 3.21 Hoist presently at tipple area.

The tipple and hoist worked together to bring the cars of coal out of the mine. As the cars approached the tipple a signal was given and the hoist which pulled the cable was stopped. At the tipple the belts or scrapers would pull the coal out. Then it was washed. The coal was graded according to size and fell through different screens. Lastly, it was directed out the different shoots down to the appropriate bins where it could be loaded on to the train. (Lawson 10/12/99).

REBUILDING AN AUTHENTIC NEW RIVER VALLEY MINER'S HOUSE

After the park has been well established, one other possibility to be considered is moving an authentic New River Valley miner’s house to the Coal Mining Heritage Park. In contrast to the "reconstructed" houses discussed earlier in this chapter, we are speaking here about rebuilding an actual historic structure rather than a replica. The Coal Mining Heritage Association presently owns one of the last remaining miner’s houses, if not the last one, and it is interested in finding a new site for the house where it will be protected and appreciated for its historic value. This would truly be a valuable addition to the park, but one which we do not recommend undertaking until the park has become well established and has a good security infrastructure. Proper security is a "must" to protect such a building from vandalism. At a later stage in the park development, however, Montgomery County and the Coal Mining Heritage Association may wish to discuss possibilities for moving this authentic miner’s house to Merrimac as a joint county-community effort. The benefits would be to enhance the park’s role in preserving the region’s mining heritage, by placing an authentic structure on exhibit. The drawbacks are in providing a safe environment and acquiring adequate funding to ensure accurate reconstruction by a firm specializing in historic preservation. Explore Park and the Beckley Coal Mining Museum, institutions that have experience resituating and exhibiting authentic structures, should be consulted at that time as to the pros and cons involved in using authentic historic structures.

As mentioned, the Coal Mining Heritage Association is in possession of the last remaining miner’s house in the New River Valley. The Coal Mining Heritage Association contracted with an historic architect to disassemble and document the last standing miner’s house in Coal Bank Hollow in 1996. A photograph and description of this house by Hazel Hodge, who once resided in it, appears earlier in this chapter (see Figure 3.7). The house is presently dismantled and stored in a barn, awaiting a new home. Since the Coal Mining Heritage Park is focused on preserving the county’s mining history, it would be appropriate to "save" this last mining house by giving it a home on the park site. Documentation on the house, its condition, and documentation needed for accurate reconstruction, can be obtained through the Coal Mining Heritage Association. Many members of the Coal Mining Heritage Association who assisted in dismantling the house have indicated their willingness to help rebuild the house at a later time. A county-community joint effort to rebuild this historic building for the public might provide a wonderful opportunity for community involvement in the heritage park, which in turn would support and facilitate successive developments at the park.

In conclusion, there are numerous possibilities for developing additional historical structures as part of the long-range heritage educational goal for Merrimac’s Coal Mining Heritage Park. Here we have described the commissary, combined shops, buildings that a miner visited on his daily routine, the tipple, and lastly, the rebuilding of an authentic miner’s house. We would not expect all of these options to be developed immediately, however, we have described the function and appearance of some of the more important buildings to be considered in the long-range goals of the park.

PHASING AND RECOMMENDATIONS FOR HERITAGE ASPECTS OF THE PARK

Decisions about the implementation of the park involve deciding which features should be constructed in what order. For the heritage aspects of the park, we recommend that several of the signs (discussed above) should be put in place at the very beginning of the park's development to give people a sense of progress and to bolster interest and enthusiasm. For Phase One in the park's development, we recommend construction and placement of the welcome signs at the three entrances. Also for Phase One, we recommend that attention be focused on developing the "Tipple Heritage Area" as the initial heritage focal point for the park. This involves establishing the larger signs at the "Tipple Heritage Area," which provide general information about coal mining in the New River Valley. It also involves setting up the outdoor exhibit of the hoist mechanism, coal cars and track, and the corresponding sign explaining this equipment. The "Heritage Bridge" should also be constructed over the tipple foundation at this time, if possible, to create a central exhibit feature that will serve as the park's initial information center and to provide an area for park dedications and other ceremonies.

Several other signs should be put up as soon as possible, preferably during Phase One, to identify other areas of heritage interest along the Huckleberry Trail. "The Miner’s Town" sign and "Bunker Hill" sign (described above) should be erected toward the eastern part of the Huckleberry Trail, and signs identifying the old hotel and commissary sites should be erected on the western side of the park. With heritage signs on the east and west, and the Tipple Heritage Area in the middle, visitors will be drawn along from one side of the park to the other.

The rest of the heritage signs should be put up as applicable to the other park developments. As the low-impact trails are constructed on the southern side of the Huckleberry, the heritage signs for those trails should also be put in place Trail (recommended for Phase Three, following the construction of the Community Recreation Area in Phase Two). The numbered post markers identifying the minor industrial buildings would be very inexpensive and easy to install. Similarly, heritage signs should be put in place when the trails are constructed on the north side of the Huckleberry Trail (recommended for Phase Four). Work on developing an archaeological exhibit at the ruins of the old supervisor's house, a destination along the Miner's House Trail, should be timed to take place when that trail is constructed (Phase Four). We have recommended that the first heritage structure, the replica of a miner's house, be constructed during Phase Five, and the Museum/Visitors Center be constructed during Phase Six.

There are several possibilities for other heritage reconstructions and interpretive exhibits at the park that could be added when the park has been well established. At that time (Phase Seven in our scheme), the possibilities/potentials for other reconstructed buildings should be evaluated and pursued if feasible. One of the most interesting possibilities is the reconstruction of an actual New River Valley miner's house, the mining house that the Coal Mining Heritage Association rescued, dismantled, and is storing until an appropriate site is found (as described above). The placement of an actual miner's house in the park, as a cooperative endeavor between the county and the CMHA, would lend authenticity and interest to the park. Other ideas for long-term possibilities include reconstructing the tipple, the hoist house, and many of the other important buildings the pertained to mining life. These propositions have not been assessed by means other than expedient wishes and would need to be assessed individually at the appropriate time.

One concern that our research team has is that the entire historic Merrimac site be kept intact. At this time, some portions of historic Merrimac still lie outside the park boundaries. The site of the old hotel is currently outside the park. But, of even greater concern, is the fact that most of Bunker Hill, the residential area where mining families lived in company houses, is separated from the park. It appears that the county only owns the lower portion of Bunker Hill -- containing the lower two house foundations. Bunker Hill is a necessary feature to include in the Coal Mining Heritage Park because of its historical significance. The majority of mining life happened in this area -- the life of mining women and children, as well as the men. Historic interpretation in the industrial section of Merrimac, within the park, will focus much on what the men did throughout their days. But what about the women and children? Most of their activities centered around the homes. Without the activities in the residential area, none of the mining activities as we know them could have occurred. A portrayal of life at Merrimac would be incomplete without incorporating Bunker Hill in the park. This land needs to be added to the park to complete the heritage map of Merrimac. We urge the county to work with the park's neighbors to purchase of the remainder of Bunker Hill so that historic Merrimac remains intact, and can be preserved and interpreted to the public as a whole.

CONCLUSION

The Coal Mining Heritage Park presents us with a wonderful opportunity for heritage conservation and preservation that will provide the community with a story of its roots. In this chapter, we have detailed a set of recommendations for presenting the heritage of the region's coal mining in the park. From the initial signs erected, to placing the finishing touches on the miner’s house, all of these ideas contribute to saving a special piece of local history. We have designed the heritage aspects of the park to impart the rich history of coal mining, while at the same time integrating the heritage aspects with other recreational activities at the park (trails and other activities that will be discussed in the following chapters). We have designed many different facets for learning about the coal mining heritage and tried to portray a broad spectrum of the opportunities to learn what it was like in all of the aspects of mining life - from digging the coal, to getting food, to catching a ride into town for supplies, and many others aspects of life.

It is important to view the heritage plans for this park as a whole integrated unit, and not just as individual unrelated pieces. We have taken great care to unite all of the ideas into a complete vision for the park. As each part is phased in, it will build a more complete picture of mining life. The signs, exhibits, heritage trails, and reconstructed buildings will give park visitors opportunities to learn in multiple ways about the strong history of an all but forgotten era. We owe it to ourselves to create the Coal Mining Heritage Park, but even more we owe it to the miners and their families to give a little back of what they gave us all, for we would not be here had it not been for those who made this area what it is today.

 

 

<< The Park Plan and Suggested Phasing Conveniences and Facilities at the Coal Mining Heritage Park >>
Planning and GIS Services
bullet Coal Mining Heritage Park
bullet Coal Heritage Park Science Center
bullet Radford U Anthropology Study and Park Plan
bullet Geotechnical Studies
bullet Hydrology Studies
bullet Coal Mining Heritage Park Annual Report
bullet Forms, Publications and News
bullet Sign on to the MontVa.com E-mail Lists.

 


The Official Site of Montgomery County Government.
Montgomery County is an equal opportunity employer and provider of services.